To add on to the Complete Guide to Canada's Robo Advisors, here at Young and Thrifty, we would like to take a closer look at the big robo advisor companies in Canada.
To start, we're checking out ModernAdvisor, which is one of the new kids on the block. There are a few things that make ModernAdvisor unique. First and foremost, ModernAdvisor offers the most competitive fees for people who don't have $500,000 to invest. They have a Springboard program where they allow you to demo the account with $1000 of ‘play' money which can become “real” when you fund the account. They also have responsible (aka ethical) investing that has the same competitive fees as ‘regular' non-socially responsible investing. It's like getting the free range organic groceries for the same price as regular.
Modern Advisor Review Summary
Who's Behind ModernAdvisor?
- ModernAdvisor was cofounded by Navid Boostani and Adrian Brouwers.
- Navid Boostani is the CEO of ModernAdvisor. He has a background in electromechanical engineering and got his credentials as a CFA (Certified Financial Analyst) a few years later.
- ModernAdvisor is based out of Vancouver.
- Credential Securities Inc. (“Credential”) holds your assets and accounts and ModernAdvisor acts as a broker-dealer. Credential is Canadian-owned; the Provincial Credit Union Centrals own 50%.
- Many investment dealers and credit unions use Credential to hold their clients’ investment accounts, execute trades, provide tax reporting and other back-office account administration.
- Credential safeguards over $20 billion for Canadian financial institutions and is a member of the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada IIROC and the Canadian Investor Protection Fund CIPF
ModernAdvisor is registered as a Restricted Portfolio Manager with the securities commissions of all provinces in Canada and the Northwest Territories. You can check the registration of investment managers here. As a Portfolio Manager ModernAdvisor is held to a fiduciary standard. This is a pretty big deal in Canada because it means that legally the company must put your best interests first – a legal standard that someone who gives themselves the title “Money Coach” or “Financial Adivsor” does not have to meet.
ModernAdvisor Review: How it Looks and Ease of Use
ModernAdvisor has clean graphics and a minimalist look. It's aesthetically pleasing because it is in white and different shades of blue. It's also very easy to use and navigate. There's a pop up that frequently asks you if you need any help via a handy chat box. This makes it seem like someone is there 24/7. You can also schedule a call with the ModernAdvisor team for more financial advice if needed. I like this idea of scheduling a call because nothing is worse than waiting on the phone for 2 hours + for someone to talk to you. As with most of the robos, ModernAdvisor is eager to engage with you in any manner that does not require them to meet face-to-face.
As stated on their website, you can access your account on your desktop or mobile device, and get help by phone, email, or online chat.
How it Works
Every company has a different type way of automatically re-balancing your investment dollars. For ModernAdvisor, they automatically re-balance your asset allocation if there is more than 5% difference from the original investment.
So there isn't a scheduled time when you are supposed to see that your Robo Advisor is re-balancing your portfolio, but it will happen automatically whenever there is an absolute difference of 5% (high or lower) from the original investment. Basically the robo is there to keep your risk profile the same as the one you first decided on. You don't want stocks or bonds to become too large a percentage of your portfolio, so they automatically sell a bit of one asset class (usually a class that is doing well) to do purchase more of another asset class (usually one that is doing relatively poorly).
What ModernAdvisor Costs:
ModernAdvisor was kind enough to offer Young and Thrifty readers a chance to invest up to $50,000 absolutely free of fees for one year. To get that deal, click here. After that, they charge a fixed percentage on your total invested assets:
To summarize, ModernAdvisor charges you a:
- 0.5% robo advisor fee on the total value of your account, if your account value is >$10,000 and <$100,000 (I'm going to call this a robo advisor fee and it includes trades that are within the account)
- If your account is <$10,000 then it is FREE
- If your investment value is >$100,000 but <$500,000 the fee is 0.4%
- If it is >$500,000 the fee becomes 0.35%
On top of this amount, there is a 0.27% Exchange Traded Fund Fee (depending on how much the ETF portfolio cost)… so the total cost can be around 0.77%, which is much less than a 2.5% that an average Canadian mutual fund would charge you for a single Canadian equity fund. It's also substantially less than major Canadian bank competitors such as BMO SmartFolio and RBC InvestEase.
The management fee is tax deductible if you have your investments in a non-registered account.
ModernAdvisor Review: Type of Accounts Offered
The types of a accounts offered through ModernAdvisor include:
- Individual RRSP
- Non-registered accounts
- Joint- Right of Survivorship
- Individual and Spousal RRIF
- Individual and Family RESP
- Locked in Retirement Account (LIRA)
Since ModernAdvisor is cofounded by a millennial, he knows what millennials want – and that's an option for responsible investing. Which means looking for companies that have environmental and social governance factors that are responsible and transparent.
Responsible (aka social or ethical) investing is an umbrella term that encompasses several investment strategies, including ESG (environment, social, governance) investing, green investing, impact investing and values-based investing. ModernAdvisor offers responsible investment options via ESG portfolios, as well as Canadian and emerging market government bond ETFs and real estate investment trusts.
Free Trial for 30 Days (and You Can Keep the Gains)
Another thing unique with ModernAdvisor is that you can start a free trial account funded with $1000 of ModernAdvisor's money called Springboard, and then keep the gains earned during the free trial (provided that you open up a real account) once the trial finishes. If you don't make any gains, you can still open up the account for free. It seems like a great way to get comfortable with investing in the stock market and see what investing with a Robo Advisor is like before fully committing.
Mutual Fund Fee Analyzer
This looks almost like a fun party trick, but if you put in your mutual funds, the mutual fund fee analyzer will spit out the amount of mutual fund fees that you pay (and that are usually not disclosed to you or that you are unaware about). You can input it manually or they will scan your documents for you and spit out your summary report.
This helps to show you the amount of fees that you are not realizing that you are paying, and help you see what a difference lower fees makes for the bottom line of your retirement dollars. The difference can be astounding. I'm definitely going to use this feature to show some of my friends what they are sacrificing by going with the path of least resistance in using bank mutual funds.
A Peek Inside ModernAdvisor
We opened up a trial ModernAdvisor account and had a look at what the platform looks like and how this Robo Advisor goes about advising on the trial investments.
First off, ModernAdvisor started by understanding my risk tolerance, my age, and the amount I wanted invested, as well as asking what my goals were.
A few pictures below show screen shots of the assessment of my investing personality and my risk level. They deemed my risk level to be moderate and created an ETF portfolio to match my level of risk.
Then it summarizes my investment style, I am deemed “moderate”.
After understanding the risk tolerance, inputting my free $1,000, and answering a few more questions (it didn't take very long, I think under 15 minutes or so). Afterwards, the money I invested in the trial account is allocated to the varying ETFs in the portfolio created based on my risk level. The low fee Exchange Traded Funds that ModernAdvisor uses are a select few and have a mirror image of the socially responsible Exchange Traded Fund they use for those who want to invest via socially responsible means.
The Exchange Traded Funds that ModernAdvisor uses are:
- XIC- iShares Core S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index ETF
- XEN- iShares Jantzi Social Index ETF
- VUS- Vanguard US Total Market ETF (Canadian dollar hedged)
- DSI- iShares MSCI KLD 400 Social ETF
- VEF- Non-North American Developed Market ETF (Canadian dollar hedged)
- VEE- Vanguard Emerging Markets ETF
- VSB- Vanguard Canadian Short-Term Bond
- CLF- iShares 1-5 Year Laddered Government Bond Index ETF (no corporate bonds, only government bonds, the socially responsible alternative to VSB)
- ZEF- BMO Emerging Markets Bond (Canadian Index hedged), invests in bonds from countries such as South Korea, Russia, Mexico and Indonesia
- VRE- Vanguard Canadian Capped REITs Infex ETF (Real Estate Investment Trusts)- the interesting thing here is that they have a very low assets under management, only $94 million. ModernAdvisor states that they use this particular ETF because it is the least costly one available.
There you have, a comprehensive summary on the low down of ModernAdvisor and a glimpse of what ModernAdvisor looks like when you start to you use it.
Act Now! How to Open a ModernAdvisor Account
Just make sure you have the information below handy and then click here to open an account at ModernAdvisor and instantly get $50,000 managed for free – for a full year – with our exclusive Modern Advisor promo offer code.
- Your social insurance number (SIN)
- Your beneficiary’s SIN (if applicable
- Images of the front and back of a piece of government issued photo ID
- An image of a recent bank account statement or screenshot from your online banking
- Your bank account information (a cheque is the easiest method)
If you've recently tried their services, please feel free to add to our Modern Advisor review below. The more first-hand experience the better!